React vs. Web Components
React and Web Components are both approaches for building reusable UI elements, but they differ in scope, implementation, and compatibility across projects and frameworks.
The topic can't be put into a single post so instead a deep dive here’s a quick comparison to highlight their strengths and distinctions with a couple of sources if you want to dig deeper into the subject.
React Components: Built using JavaScript and JSX syntax, React components are tied to the React ecosystem. They rely on React’s virtual DOM for efficient rendering and require the React library to function.
Web Components: Web Components are a set of standardized APIs (like Custom Elements, Shadow DOM, and HTML templates) that work natively in browsers, allowing them to be used independently of frameworks. They are part of the web platform, making them framework-agnostic.
React Components: React uses a virtual DOM to update the UI efficiently, performing diffing and reconciliation to minimize direct DOM manipulation. Its performance is generally good, especially for applications that need frequent updates.
Web Components: Web Components manipulate the actual DOM directly, which can benefit certain performance use cases, especially in lightweight applications. However, they lack React's virtual DOM optimizations, which can affect performance in dynamic apps with frequent state changes.
React Components: Styling is typically handled using CSS-in-JS solutions (e.g., styled components, Emotion) or external CSS files. It’s scoped at the component level but without native encapsulation.
Web Components: Web Components use the Shadow DOM, which provides native encapsulation, isolating styles and structure so that they don’t leak out or get affected by external CSS. This makes them ideal for building isolated, self-contained components that the surrounding styles won’t influence.
React Components: React components are highly reusable within React applications but are generally limited to React-based projects. Additional steps like wrappers or adaptations are needed to use them outside of React.
Web Components: Web Components are inherently reusable across any project or framework (e.g., React, Vue, Angular) or in plain HTML. They follow web standards, making them ideal for cross-framework use and interoperability.
React Components: React has a steep learning curve due to concepts like hooks, the virtual DOM, and JSX. However, React has a rich ecosystem, extensive documentation, and a large community, making it easier to find resources and support.
Web Components: Web Components use standardized web APIs, meaning developers familiar with native JavaScript and HTML will find them relatively easy to learn. However, since Web Components lack the sophisticated state management and lifecycle methods that React provides, building complex UIs might require more setup.
React Components: React has a built-in state management system, making managing the state at the component and application levels easy. Additionally, libraries like Redux or Zustand provide powerful options for larger applications.
Web Components: Web Components do not come with built-in state management. To manage state, developers often must implement custom JavaScript solutions or integrate libraries, which can add complexity to larger applications.
React Components are best suited for applications within the React ecosystem where virtual DOM, rich ecosystem tools, and state management are needed.
Web Components are ideal for cross-framework compatibility, encapsulation, and native browser support, especially in environments where framework independence is a priority.
Both approaches can be powerful depending on the project requirements, but they serve different use cases and development needs.
Further read:
Your First React Component - https://react.dev/learn/your-first-component
Server and Client Components - https://nextjs.org/learn/react-foundations/server-and-client-components
Decoding the Hype: What Are React Server Components?
Web Components - https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Web_components Web components vs. React - https://blog.logrocket.com/web-components-vs-react/ React vs Web Components – Which Is Best for Your Project? - https://www.uxpin.com/studio/blog/react-vs-web-components/